Plant Breeding Software or Spreadsheets – a million dollar difference

abundance bank banking banknotes

There are seed companies where the seed multiplication, sales and marketing staff use expensive and very current software. Meanwhile the breeders in the same company are still primarily using spreadsheets.  Think about it – the breeders who develop the hybrids and varieties that determine the rest of the “revenue pipeline” on which the company depends … Read more Plant Breeding Software or Spreadsheets – a million dollar difference

So How Much Do You Think Your Seed Company Is Worth?

If a potential buyer asks the value of your germplasm, are you prepared to give a response, and do you have the data to back it up? Any experienced breeder can look at the data and get a sense of how the program has been managed.

Your Most Important Client is Your Next One

You Are Important

I was recently evaluating bank account options. At just one bank, I could easily choose between standard, advanced, premier or private accounts. The options were seemingly endless, which as a consumer means I get more of what I need and less of what I don’t.

What I Learned from… Buying my First Compact SUV

My daughter had been telling me for a while to buy a compact SUV, I finally relented and almost immediately ran into a problem. Should I read the manual?

Hey Client! Don’t Be a Stranger

Our support staff includes two former plant breeders, which makes us ideally suited to know what our clients want and need — our staff have literally “walked in the shoes” of our customers.

Statistical Analyses Trapped in Time – And It Could Really Cost You

dreamstime_4571Years ago, when I was conducting yield trials as a plant breeder, drought seemed imminent a few months after planting. Rather than lose the entire trial, I requested sprinkler irrigation at the research station. Unfortunately, water pressure to the far end of the station wasn’t ideal, and there wasn’t a perfect fit for one of the pipe connections. I could see the tragedy unfolding: uneven irrigation perpendicular to the blocks in the randomized complete block design (RCBD) and thus a high covariance (CV).

During the season, anyone could see an obvious gradient along the plots. The plants on the left side of the trial were shorter, and the plants on the right were taller and greener. This was a statistician’s worst nightmare. Due to the conditions and variability, I thought the trial might still be a loss.

When I finally analyzed the trial, the CV was indeed high. However, around that time, I happened to come across a small software program that analyzed trials with a spatial algorithm to account for trends in the field. I wondered if it would work for me. Much to my surprise it estimated the trends and even the exact spot where the pipes didn’t connect and water gushed out for a few hours. The CV went way down, and heritability went way up.

But what shocked me most were the adjustments in the means for the varieties now estimated in the absence of confounding trends – in this case, from uneven irrigation. The RCBD analysis just gives the arithmetic mean of entries, whereas the spatial analysis estimates means in the absence of trends (estimated iteratively from solely plot data). Among the RCBD-ranked Top 5, three were actually low yielding. Furthermore, some of those ranking lower in the trial were actually among the top yielding when estimated by this spatial data analysis. It was a night-and-day difference.

dreamstime_s_70223305Which analysis would I believe? What if I chose the wrong varieties because they were incorrectly ranked? This had massive implications for my breeding program. Years later, and after further research co-published in Crop Science and American Statistician, I remain firmly convinced that nearest neighbor analysis is a simple but powerful approach in spatial analysis. It is called “nearest neighbor” because the nearest plots (the ones to the left and immediate right of a central plot) are used in the algorithm in sequence.

In the years since my discovery, I’ve had the opportunity to reanalyze yield trial data for a number of seed companies, and often, the spatial analysis proved superior with greater confidence in selecting the best hybrids and varieties. In fact, one client reanalyzed 25 years of yield data, comparing it to the RCBD and incomplete block analyses, and came to different conclusions through the spatial analysis, which was decidedly superior.

This meant somewhat different decisions as to the release of final varieties, which are million-dollar decisions for seed companies. But still, all too many companies rely on the RCBD analysis developed by Sir Ronald Fisher in the 1920s, almost as if statistical time stood still.

(First published on | May 2017)

Discover more of the statistical capabilities of AGROBASE Generation II®

Dr. Dieter Mulitze is Founder and CEO of Agronomix Software – data management and analysis software for plant breeders and variety testers. 

New Strategic Alliance for Plant Breeding Software in China

Agronomix Software, Winnipeg, Canada, is pleased to announce that as of July 23, 2018, Zealquest Scientific Technology, will be the exclusive distributor of Agronomix Software’s AGROBASE Generation II® Plant Breeding Software in the Peoples Republic of China and Taiwan.

Pushing Spreadsheets with your PhD?

Do you know how much time you, or plant breeders within your company, spend looking at spreadsheets? It might surprise you. I’ve recently had conversations with leaders at one large seed company who estimate breeders there spend about 20 percent of their time looking at spreadsheets.